Here’s wishing everyone a great Diwali and a prosperous new year ahead.
With the benchmark indices going nowhere post reaching the ATH peak, it
is time to sit back and take stock. By all counts, from traders, analysts et
al, Indian markets are trading above their fair value and there are better
options globally, and even in Asia. Nifty 50 index is trading at ~24x PE, which
is in line with its 5-year average, but a tad higher than the 10-year average
of 23.4x, as per Bloomberg data. The Nifty Midcap 100 index at 47x PE, too, is
far away from its five-year average of 36.4x and 10-year average of 32.4x, data
shows. In P/E terms, the Nifty 50, data shows, is trading at around 89% premium
to the MSCI EM index, above its historical average of around 50%. Stable
macros, broad-based earnings growth and robust banking/corporate sector health,
analysts said, are driving this premium. That said, geopolitics, US elections
and crude price remain key risks, especially post the recent escalation in the
conflict in West Asia. Any shift in government’s fiscal priorities post state
elections, can also emerge as a medium-term risk. While it is true that
prospects of Indian markets look way better than most, at least on paper, as
they say, proof of the pudding is in eating it. These are just notional and
once the results are out, the reality will be there for all to see. The concern
is that India will not be able to sustain the premium valuation it has held
since 2021. And Q2 results have given a preview of things to come.
The good thing though is that Indian retail investors have matured big
time as is seen by the steady stream of SIP flows over the last few years
irrespective of the market trend. That is indeed a heartening prospect as DIIs,
who actually use these flows, can act as a counter to the FIIs and in fact have
actually been doing so for the last few years, and this trend looks unlikely to
stop. (FII) have pulled nearly
$7 billion from Indian stocks in October alone.
The other noticeable thing which has happened is the returns the
precious metals Gold and Silver have given over the last few months. The gains
in bullion (and Silver) have been on multiple levers including geo-political
tension and hopes of more rate cuts by the US Federal Reserve, this year.
They have rubbed shoulders with equity returns, and in fact surpassed them.
In 2024 so far, Gold has
delivered returns of ~21% while silver has ~23% vs 12% yielded by the Sensex. And
with the festive fervour having already started and peaking in the next few
weeks, the party is likely to continue. So it makes eminent sense to have both
of these in your portfolio for the next year or so, at the minimum, a point I
have been making for more than the last 6 months. And there are a variety of
instruments today which give you the flexibility to do that, the way you want
to. For investors, looking for a lazy way out, you have the Multi-asset schemes
which various AMCs have floated, which would serve the purpose very well, if
one doesn’t want to spend own efforts in this area.
The major global events which are on the horizon now are the US prez.
elections and the probable Fed rate cuts in the next 2 months. And adding spice
to this heady mixture will be the state elections in India in some of the key
states like Maharashtra & Jharkhand over the next 2 months. It remains to
be seen when our very own RBI follows suits of the western world and
kick-starts the rate cut cycle.
So this time, I will be leaning more towards stock picking than a top
down sector approach as I usually do. As I have seen, there are sectors lie BFS
which have headwinds while individual stocks have tailwind and that is where
this theory plays out well. The stocks on my radar this time are likely to be
the ones which have deep value within and could go the Raymond way as you will
see in the later part. The thing is that these things are right there in front
of everybody, but nobody has really noticed them from that angle. So here are
the stocks I am betting on this year.
Edelweiss Financial Services
(EFS)
EFS has a set of rich businesses which the market has completely
ignored, a la ITC. By its own admission, here is the break-up:
And its current Mcap is only ~10500 Cr. It is quoting pretty much like a
holding company, at a massive discounteven though it has an active
participation in all its businesses, unlike a holding company which is usually
a passive investor. It has openly declared that value unlocking will happen
over a period of time. AMC & Insurance arms may be the first off the block
considering market flavour.
So this can be an ideal SIP candidate to accumulate over the next few
months taking advantage of the current market volatility. And to top it all, it
is headed by a market & finance veteran Rasesh Shah, an IIM-A alumnus who I
would rate in the same league as IDFC First Bank’s CEO Vaidyanathan, another
from the same institute and who has earned his stripes over the years. I won’t
be surprised if ESL doubles over the next couple of years with these tailwinds
and steered by such able leadership.
S H Kelkar & Company (Keva)
There are a lot of daily use FMCG products like soaps, shampoos,
detergents etc which require fragrances of various kinds. S. H. Kelkar &
Company (also known as Keva) is one such company which provides this smell or
fragrance to the makers of these products. And it has been doing this for the
last 50 years. This being a very selective and customized business, the
customers tend to take time to gain confidence in the company and contracting
is usually a long drawn process. But once Keva gets the fragrance and quality
right, the client is theirs for life. The clients are unlikely to shift to
another vendor in a hurry once the chemical set-up is achieved, resulting in
long-term supply contracts with most FMCG companies needing their products.
Keva is one of India’s largest fragrance companies. Such is their
popularity that some of the fragrances they developed decade ago are still
market leaders. They have a reach
over 90 countries, and their sensorial offerings span a large variety of
flavours, fragrances and aroma ingredients. To address this global market, they
have set up 7 Creative Development Centres across 3 continents. These serve
more than 4000 local and MNC clients with ease. We’ve
also achieved significant backward integration capabilities in our fragrances
division through 6 manufacturing plants. Keva manufactures both fragrances and
the aroma ingredients that go into them. This allows them substantial
flexibility in effectively responding to changes in demand. This has enabled
them to have a steady growth rate of 12-15% over the last several years.
The major risk factor for Keva is that this is a B2B
business and is impacted by the rise in inputs costs which can’t be easily
passed on to the clients. This has the effect of impacting operating margins
for a few quarters before the cycle eventually turns.
Currently it is quoting at very attractive valuations.
This being a stable quality business, has all the potential to grow and scale
up in double digits for several years. While the SMID stocks are quoting at
huge multiples and have gone up upwards of 3x, this has gone up less than 2x,
and is quoting at around 36 PE which makes it a value play. It has a great long
term potential and if one were to think of long term, this would be a prime
pick at current levels. This being in the fragrances and food additives
business, can be considered as a direct play on the Consumption theme. Add to
it the China+1 strategy which is fast catching up in the western world, and the
growth story is further reinforced. Keva will surely be able to capture a
larger global market and has the potential to be a mutli-bagger.
Losing ground in the current correction to below 300, this
provides a great opportunity to add such a niche stock to one’s portfolio.
Arihant Superstructures (AS)
I consider this as a proxy play on the new airport coming
in Navi Mumbai. This is a mid-sized player in MMR. Its focus is on the MMR
micro markets of Badlapur, Shilphata, Taloja, Kalyan etc. which are in close
proximity to the upcoming airport as well as the prime pockets like Vashi,
Kharghar and the upcoming Panvel. It also has 20% of its projects coming in
from Jodhpur, another upcoming real estate pocket in Rajasthan. Panvel
constitutes another 20% of its projects. It thus boasts of a blend of luxurious
as well as affordable housing projects across these areas, with these 2 lucrative
pockets constituting 40% of its strength. It has a launch pipeline of close to
1000 Cr. in the current financial year.
The current airport in Mumbai has a capacity of 50 million
passengers/year while the upcoming Navi Mumbai airport boasts of a capacity of
20 million passengers/year. As with any such major landmark, this too has the
potential to create a mini- Navi Mumbai once the airport becomes operational in
2025. For those of you who are not aware, you just have to look at how the
property prices have mushroomed at the Maharashtra-Goa border of Sawantwadi and
neighbouring areas, most of the land there being cornered by politicians of
both sides. And guess the reason? The swanky new airport in Goa (its second,
the first one being run by the defence establishment) at Mopa just across this
border. And thanks to this, these areas have moved up from being sleepy
villages they were not too far back to buzzing towns of economic activity. This
is what a major landmark like airport has the potential of creating. The same
fate now awaits the hitherto neglected area at the far end of what we currently
know as Navi Mumbai, though after such a long time, it has become somewhat of a
misnomer, Navi meaning ‘new’ in Marathi. Already, the signs of awakening are
visible. The big boys of India Inc are already here with purchases of huge land
banks. Reliance is setting up an industrial park in this area close to its
existing DAKC, Adani’s Data centres are coming up at Taloja, new sea ports are
coming up at Dighi in the same area and many such huge infrastructure projects
are in the works. This obviously will give rise to prime real estate in the
whole area and this could well be the next Powai.
AS is already here with 37 projects of which 21 are low
inventory, ready-to-move ones, which usually sell like hot cakes. AS is also
into the much sought after affordable housing. They are known for being
customer-friendly with no transfer pricing and lock-ins. However the icing on
the cake is the Arihant‘s luxury villas project called as Arihant World Villas
spread over 76 acres, just 30 min away from the new airport. The plan is to
have 362 villas with a gross development potential of ₹1000 Cr. for the
discerning few. Needless to say, 5* amenities like Golfing, Spa resort, Clubs,
Riverside promenades, Mall etc are all planned for a complete well heeled
experience. Along with this, 2 big 5* 200+ room hotels managed by Indian Hotels
(Taj), are also proposed. Market cap of the company is just ~₹1400 Cr. And all
this when it has shown a 5-year PAT CAGR of 40%.And the stock price too has
delivered a CAGR of 20% in this period. The thing to note is that all of this
has happened prior to the airport being started. So considering all of the
above factors, this looks like a big re-rating candidate. Even after the
current run-up, even if it takes a pause for a while, with the opening of the
airport in a year’s time, I am sure smart hands will start accumulating soon,
if not done already.
Indigo Paints (IP)
This is the smallest paints company among the listed ones with a MCap of less than 10K Cr. while most of the others are upwards of 20K Cr. with only Akzo Nobel slightly below this. And yet IP is half the size of the smallest of the established players. Yet, it is holding its own among strong competition from the larger players and few of the big houses entering it recently – Birla Opus, JSW Paints etc.
IP was incorporated in year 2000 and manufactures and sell decorative paints. MS Dhoni is its brand ambassador which fits in quite well with its image as a cool brand. It is the 1st company in India to introduce category creator products like metallic emulsions, tile coating emulsions etc. in the decorative paints segment. The company has a market share of 80-90% in some of its differentiated products. Its product basket comprises of emulsions, enamels, wood coatings, cement paints and putties, premiere distempers etc. They have a distribution network in 28 states with 18000 active dealers, 7000 tinting machines and 53 depots in India. The company also has 5 manufacturing sites.
Its sales have nearly doubled in 3 years, and OPM has gone up from 13 to 22%, a no mean feat in a competitive environment. ROCE has consistently been above 20% over the last few years. And as is the trend, public holding has been decreasing over the last few years while institutional holding is increasing, so much so that the public holds just 17% currently. It is therefore safe to conclude that it is in strong hands.
Given the state of the economy, govt’s push for housing and infrastructure, paint industry despite multiple players has string tailwinds which will benefit a smaller, agile player like IP much more than the biggies. This has been consolidating over the last 2 years and has gone nowhere. It therefore looks like an opportune time to board this and play with patience over the next few years to really get the compounding benefit. Add to it the ever present option of consolidation or sell-out to one of the biggies with deep pockets, gains can still be made.
India Glycols
This company has a Distillery business where Ethanol is manufactured, a Liquor business and finally, the Speciality chemicals business. All 3 r not only going great guns at present, but their future looks equally bright. Speciality chemicals sector has taken a beating in the last 2 years and can now be considered to have bottomed out. We all know how close Ethanol is to Gadkari’s heart and Liquor is an evergreen business, especially the IMFL one. You just have to look at Associated Alcohols in the last 1 year or so to understand what I mean.
Having said the above, I believe that there is a great scope for value unlocking here as all the 3 businesses is strong in their own right. And as has often been seen, SOTP is usually way higher than the individual parts together. So even though it has doubled over the last year, there r enough tailwinds for it to go higher. And this will unravel over the next few months/years.
Since last Diwali which was celebrated on November 12, 2023, the headline Nifty index so far has risen by a sharp over 26%. Nifty Midcap 100 index also reportedly gained 39% during the review period, with the recent debutant IREDA leading with gains of as much as 232%.
During the period under study, Nifty Smallcap index also buzzed and gained 37%. And as we are set to usher in a new Samvat 2081 this Diwali, here's a look at how our portfolio has performed.
|
2023 |
2024 |
Difference |
Gain/Loss |
SEPC |
24.25 |
26.15 |
1.90 |
7.84% |
Orient Green Power |
17.45 |
19.04 |
1.59 |
9.11% |
Raymond* |
1880.88 |
1635.85 |
-245.03 |
-13.03% |
Raymond Lifestyle |
8.02 |
1768.88 |
1760.86 |
21962.97% |
TNPL |
286.00 |
178.30 |
-107.70 |
-37.66% |
Federal Mogul Goetze |
358.60 |
396.45 |
37.85 |
10.55% |
Total |
2575.20 |
4024.67 |
1449.47 |
56.29% |
Apart from the underperforming TNPL, rest of the stocks performed well in line with expectations. 2 of the 5 are from Infra (SEPC) & Power sectors (OGP) which are potential multibaggers in the next few years. Even the underperformer TNPL holds a lot of promise which should emerge in the years to come and I would not write it off just yet. To be fair, most of the gains in the current portfolio were driven by Raymond, and this only shows how badly the market had underestimated its deep potential over the years. I have written on it in depth last year and the story has certainly played out to script. As I have said, Raymond is not done yet and there is still steam left. 2 of its businesses are ripe for demerger and it will be a matter of time when it happens. It is more a question of when rather than if. This is exactly the kind of value unlocking story one should look out for. 2 of the current year’s stocks (ESL & India Glycols) are exactly these, and could go the Raymond way if one has the patience to hold them thru ups and downs (which would certainly come due to unforeseen events).
This year was highly satisfactory with an overall return of ~56%, well above the Small cap index returns of 37%, the category to which all of them belong and way better than the returns of other indices, as expected. Of course, there are a host of other stocks on both sides, ones which gave 2x, 3x returns and ones which lost a lot of ground, mostly among large caps like IndusInd Bank which lost close to 30%, most of it in the last few days since its results. And the other set of stocks which took a beating was the Defence and Railways pack which has retreated anywhere from 20-40% from their peaks. However, there is nothing to feel sad about for them as they have gone up by 400-500% (or more in some cases) in just 2 years and so a loss of 40% should not worry one unduly. Even after retreating so much from their highs, one would still be sitting on multibagger returns in most of these stocks.
The current picks are again a bet on India’s Infra & Consumption story which should play out in the coming years, once the current volatility subsides. The risks obviously are more geopolitical than local, the major worry being the spill over of the geopolitical issues on us primarily in oil which have the potential to cascade and spoil the local party. Only time will tell how it all pans out. Considering that all of them are small caps, you may certainly expect volatility in the coming quarters and year but also steady compounding (probably market-beating) over a longer timeframe with this lot.
Though Banking stocks have taken a beating for some time now, and are not likely to recover in a hurry, it is the rest of the FS space that merits an attention for 2 reasons – 1) Banks have lending issues, be it the cost of funds or the quality of borrowers 2) rest of the FS space is under penetrated. Look at Insurance. There is still a long runway for these stocks as people, especially youngsters, become more educated about insurance, and govt. makes some types of insurance mandatory or easily accessible for these firms to market it. 3) Equity investing as a cult is still to make a mark in India, even though the no. of people and demat accounts have doubled and tripled in the last 4 years. There is still a vast population who haven’t dabbled in direct equities yet, for various reasons. And this is a huge market.
The last thing that I want to leave you with is that though equities as an asset class are considered as inflation-beating over the long term, which is certainly true, we are at the cusp of debt asset class resurgence as well. It is only a matter of time, a quarter or two, when RBI will start the rate cut cycle and this will lead to double-digit inflation beating returns in debt as well. Already, market pundits have sounded a note of caution on expectations from equity markets this year due to all the things mentioned above. It is time to rebalance the portfolio with a generous slice of debt and leave the equity class as-is w/o being too adventurous. One should ideally try to lock into the high yields of NCDs/FDs etc which are available now (even considering the tax angle) and also consider long duration and Gilt debt mutual funds which will start giving the expected double digit returns over the next 2-3 years, depending on when the rate cut cycle starts.
HAPPY MUHURAT TRADING!!